TL;DR – The polite Best Offer playbook

1. Know the market first: check sold prices so your offer is grounded.
2. Offer with intent: make an amount you’ll happily pay right now.
3. Be brief and human: one sentence, friendly tone, no lectures.
4. Respect the gap: tiny discounts are fine on hot items; bigger gaps need reasons.
5. Don’t nickel‑and‑dime: avoid serial counter‑offers and $1 haggling.
6. Use timing wisely: watchers, end‑of‑month, or after a price drop can work.
7. If it feels off, walk away: another listing will come.

Disclosure: This article may contain affiliate links. We may earn from qualifying purchases—at no extra cost to you.

---

Why “Best Offer” can be great (and why it sometimes goes badly)

Best Offer is one of the simplest ways to get a better deal online. Done well, it’s a quick, respectful negotiation that saves both buyer and seller time. Done badly, it becomes lowballing, endless back‑and‑forth, or weird messages that make sellers hit “Decline” on principle.

If you’ve ever worried about sounding pushy—or you’ve received a counter‑offer that felt random—this guide gives you a clean approach you can reuse in any category.

Step 1: Do 3 minutes of homework before you offer

A good offer starts with reality. Before you type a number, look at sold/completed listings for the same model, size, edition, or comparable condition. If you can’t find exact matches, look for close substitutes and adjust for condition and what’s included.

This protects you two ways. It keeps you from overpaying when a seller is aiming high, and it keeps you from under‑offering when the item is genuinely scarce. Sellers can tell when an offer is anchored in the market versus pulled from the air.

Step 2: Decide your “happy price” (and your walk‑away price)

Your “happy price” is what you’d be glad to pay right now without regret. Your walk‑away price is the maximum you’ll pay if the seller counters. Once you have those numbers, Best Offer becomes easy: you’re not negotiating with your emotions, you’re negotiating with a plan.

This also prevents the classic mistake: sending a low offer “just to see,” then feeling awkward when it gets accepted.

Step 3: Understand the seller’s side (it makes your offer stronger)

Sellers juggle fees, packing time, returns risk, and the simple fact that some items take ages to sell. A reasonable offer saves them time and uncertainty. What sellers generally dislike is being treated as if they’re running a yard sale while they’re trying to run a process.

If you remember one principle, make it this: the best offers feel like a quick win for both sides.

Step 4: How much below asking is reasonable?

There’s no universal percentage, but there is a practical range.

If the price is already at market, the best offer might be small—think “rounding down,” a shipping offset, or a modest discount. If the listing is clearly above sold prices, you can offer lower with confidence, but it helps to be polite and matter‑of‑fact.

Condition, completeness, and demand matter. An item that’s rare, trending, or priced aggressively doesn’t need a big discount to be a fair deal. An item with flaws, missing accessories, or a long time on the market can justify a larger gap.

Step 5: Write the message the seller wants to accept

Most offers don’t need a long explanation. A short note can help, but only if it’s friendly and specific.

Good offer notes have three qualities: they are brief, they show you’re ready to pay now, and they avoid sounding entitled. Bad offer notes are long, emotional, or lecture the seller about how they should price their own item.

Here are a few templates you can paste and adjust:

Hi! I can offer [your price] and pay immediately. Thanks for considering.

Hi there—based on recent sold prices, I can do [your price] today and pay straight away.

Thanks! I’m interested—would you take [your price]? I can pay now.

If you’re making a larger discount request, keep it calm:

Hi—similar items have been selling around [range]. I can offer [your price] and pay today. No worries if it’s too low.

That last line (“no worries”) matters more than it seems. It tells the seller you’re not going to argue.

Step 6: Avoid the “That Buyer” behaviours

You don’t need to be perfect—just avoid the patterns that make sellers shut down.

One is the extreme lowball with no context. Another is the slow, tiny counter‑offers: dropping or raising by a dollar, trying to “win” the negotiation rather than close it. Another is bundling demands into the offer message (“drop the price and upgrade shipping and include extras”).

Also avoid making the seller do work before you commit. It’s fine to ask one clear question, but try not to ask for a dozen photos, three measurements, and then send a vague offer.

Step 7: How to respond to counter‑offers

A counter‑offer is useful information: it reveals the seller’s floor (or at least their current willingness). Don’t take it personally.

If the counter is within your walk‑away price, accept and move on. If it’s not, you have two clean options: decline politely, or counter once with your real maximum and a short note.

Here are two lines that work well:

Thanks for the counter. My best is [your max]—happy to pay now.

Appreciate it—[your max] is the highest I can do. No worries if you’d rather hold out.

The goal is to avoid turning negotiation into a conversation. One counter is usually enough.

Step 8: Timing that can help (without being weird)

Best Offer isn’t just about price—it’s about context. Some moments naturally increase your chances.

If an item has been listed for a while, the seller may be more flexible. If you see a recent price drop, it can signal the seller is trying to move it. If you’re a watcher, sellers sometimes send discounts; you can respond quickly with a clean offer.

That said, you don’t need “hacks.” A fair offer plus fast payment beats clever timing most of the time.

Step 9: Bundling and combined shipping (the polite way)

If a seller has multiple items you want, bundling can benefit both sides. Ask for combined shipping first, then make a single offer that feels straightforward.

Here’s a message that stays respectful:

Hi! I’m interested in Item A and Item B—could you do combined shipping to [postcode/ZIP]? If so, I can offer [bundle price] for both and pay today.

Keep it simple and give the seller an easy “yes.”

Step 10: When to walk away

The most underrated buyer skill is knowing when not to buy. If the seller becomes aggressive, the listing is vague, key details can’t be confirmed, or the negotiation starts feeling like a tug‑of‑war, step back.

Walking away isn’t losing. It’s protecting your time, your budget, and your future self from a frustrating parcel and a return process.

Final thought

Best Offer works when it feels like a respectful shortcut: you’ve done your homework, you’ve chosen a number you’re happy with, and you’ve made it easy for the seller to accept. Be brief, be ready to pay, and treat the other person like a human.

If the seller declines, it doesn’t mean your offer was “wrong.” It just means you didn’t overlap on price today. Another listing will come—and you’ll be ready.

Shop with us

Love our guides? Browse our latest finds on eBay — Visit our eBay store. When you shop via some links on this site, we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.